Tuesday's meeting of the San Ramon City Council marked the end of one era and the beginning of another.
Councilmember Jim Livingstone was honored as he retired after decades of service for the city of San Ramon, and Harry Sachs was sworn in as the newest councilmember.
Livingstone tearfully accepted proclamations and gifts, kind words and hugs from his colleagues on the council, staff members, family and friends.
Then he gave some parting words of advice, including the "HOV lanes that nobody wants to address because there are some of you citizens that are very against those HOV lanes."
Livingstone said that the proposed Norris Canyon high occupancy vehicle (HOV) are important because they will move some traffic off Crow Canyon and Bollinger Canyon roads. Some neighbors have voiced opposition to the project.
Livingstone said, "As council members you will need to make some touch calls. You will make some people unhappy."
"For you council members to bow down to a small little group, shame on you!"
Referencing the Thomas Burnett Jr. Memorial Bridge (Fostoria Way overcrossing Interstate 680), Livingstone said that if the small group of citizens who opposed that project had stopped it, "we would not be in very good shape."
"We as council people are elected to make decisions," Livingston said. "Decision doesn't mean go study it some more. That's why Costco is in Danville. It should be in San Ramon.
"Because the city council didn't have the guts to make the decision, Danville got the Costco. Good for Danville. But you know that sidewalk in front of Costco? It's in San Ramon. So San Ramon got all the traffic and Danville got all the money."
Livingstone was able to reference events in San Ramon's history from "way back in the 1980s," the 1990s and 2000s so clearly because he has been in community service for several decades.
He was part of the San Ramon incorporation effort, which came to fruition in 1983. He was appointed to the Planning Commission in July 1994 and served until June 2002.
During his tenure, he served as chair of the Commission from November 1997 to June 1998 and November 2001 to June 2002, and liaison to the Architectural Review Board, Transportation Committee and Economic Development Advisory Committee.
He first served on the City Council from August to November 2001, was reappointed in January 2002, was elected in 2005 and has served since with terms as vice mayor from 2004 to 2005, 2007 to 2008 and 2011 to 2012.
Livingstone served on the Finance Committee from 2006 to 2013, including serving as chair in 2012 and 2013. He has also served as Council Liaison to the Arts, Economic Development, Transportation and Senior Citizens Advisory Committees; the Arts Foundation; the Community Emergency Response Team; the Tri-Valley Affordable Housing Committee; and the San Ramon Valley Unified School District.
Councilmember David Hudson, who was sworn in for another term on the council, said Livingstone was the "best councilman I have served with."
Harry Sachs, a teacher and former Planning Commission member, was also sworn in.
Addressing his fellow councilmembers, Sachs said, "We have many difference in our growth philosophies for the city going forward. Let's bridge our differences on how we manage our growth with transparent decision making, pragmatic decision making that values our past, that values the expertise of our city employees and also places the emphasis on the values of our residents. For, indeed, it is the residents of San Ramon that make this city truly what it is and what it can become."
Mayor Bill Clarkson was also sworn in for another term as mayor.
In his comments, citing the financial stability of the city, the award-winning school district and quality parks and open space, Clarkson said, "Building upon these assets and these great things, San Ramon is really poised to go great places.
"I know I speak for the whole council when I say to all of you how much we appreciate your support, your constructive criticism, your encouragement and your advice, and your active engagement."
Clarkson also acknowledged that this meeting was the final one for City Clerk Patricia Edwards, who is retiring at the end of the month.