Cody Hall deemed 'potential threat to human life,' remains held without bail

Tri-Valley teen pleads not guilty to all charges

The young driver charged with murder for running down and killing a bicyclist in the Tri-Valley will remain in jail without bond after a judge ruled Thursday that the teen posed "a potential threat to human life."

Cody Hall's attorney had asked for a bail of $150,000, but the prosecution argued that a safety threat existed based on a history of speeding. In one case, Hall was cited by police after being clocked at 70 mph on Foothill Road, the same place the fatal crash occurred, according to assistant District Attorney Sharon Carney.

"He also had been in a collision in August, 2011," Carney told Alameda County Superior Court Judge Jacob Blea III during the morning bail hearing in Pleasanton. "He was fully aware of the speed limit."

Carney said in that crash, Hall rear-ended another vehicle as it neared Foothill High School. The prosecutor also cited three instances in which Hall posted on social media accounts, including one in which he claimed to be driving 140 mph on Interstate 5 and said, "I can't control myself." In another post, Hall said he was driving 100 mph on W. Las Positas Boulevard, Carney added.

In addition, Carney noted that the investigation had turned up two vehicles that were totaled but were not reported to police.

Hall, 19, of Pleasanton was originally arrested for vehicular manslaughter with gross negligence and reckless driving with serious injury following the June 9 crash that killed bicyclist Diana Hersevoort, 58, of Dublin and left her husband, another rider, with a broken leg along Foothill Road in Pleasanton.

Carney told the court that Hall had crossed a double-yellow line to pass two cars, both times causing oncoming traffic to slow down.

In the second incident, court documents show, Hall was traveling 83 mph, more than twice the speed limit, when he lost control while pulling back into his lane, where he fatally struck Hersevoort and her husband before hitting a pole.

Charges against Hall were upgraded to murder in August. At an initial hearing, Judge Hugh Walker said Hall had "dug a hole so deep, I don't think he can get out of it," and order that he be held without bail.

Defense attorney Timothy Rein attempted to have the bail lowered, claiming that the evidence was available when the initial charges were filed, when Hall was released on a $100,000 bond. Rein also said a no-bail hold only applied in specific cases.

"This is not a capital case," Rein told the court. "It would appear that bail would be permissible."

In making his ruling Thursday, Blea said "the persuasive evidence of speed" qualified Hall as a threat.

Hall entered a plea of not guilty to all counts. He's set for a preliminary hearing on Feb. 5.

Hersevoort's two daughters were at the hearing, but declined to comment. About a half dozen of Hall's friends and family members also attended the hearing.


Like this comment
Posted by Julia
a resident of Alamo
on Nov 15, 2013 at 9:43 am

The SOB should be incarcerated for 10 to 15 years...

He has and attitude...let him see how far that attitude gets him the State prison system.

Thanks for Listening, Julia Pardini

Like this comment
Posted by MamatheBomba
a resident of Danville
on Nov 15, 2013 at 5:16 pm

This is a shame for the families involved. May Justice be served.

I was just on Diablo Rd, and was very rudely flipped off by two girls in a medium blue Ford Escape, CA License 6UYW876, very attractive young ladies turning right from the street from the library. If you know who they are, please ask the driver to review lane changes and right turns onto two lane streets.

They could be victims of bad driving, too.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Sound and Fury over Vile and Slur-ry
By Tom Cushing | 91 comments | 1,390 views

Time for new collaboration between city and school district
By Tim Hunt | 0 comments | 343 views