Judge considers tougher sentence for ex-local attorney who killed cyclist

'Mr. Smith has been given enormous opportunities and he hasn't complied with them,' judge says to defense's release request

A judge said Thursday that he will consider imposing a tougher sentence for an attorney and former San Ramon resident who killed a bicyclist in a hit-and-run collision in Dublin in 2012 if he concludes that the attorney misled him at sentencing hearings last year.

Spencer Freeman Smith, 36, pleaded no contest to felony hit-and-run and misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter for striking and killing 57-year-old Bo Hu on Dougherty and Fall Creek roads in Dublin on May 15, 2012, and was back in court Thursday morning.

Alameda County Superior Court Judge Michael Gaffey said of Smith, "If he's found to have intentionally misled the court, then there could be greater consequences than those that already have been imposed and there could be a different penalty."

Smith's attorney, Rebecca Feigelson, said, "I don't think that will happen," saying she doesn't think that Smith misled the court, but Gaffey told her, "You're not the judge."

Thursday's hearing was on the issue of whether Smith misled Gaffey at two sentencing hearings last fall by asking to delay serving his jail term because his wife's health was precarious.

But Gaffey postponed the matter until June 10 after Feigelson said Smith's wife can't come to court because her pregnancy is "high-risk" and she's not supposed to travel until after she gives birth, which is scheduled to happen on April 22.

Smith practiced law in San Francisco and lived in San Ramon at the time of the fatal crash that killed Hu. He and his family now live in Santa Ana in Orange County.

After Smith entered his plea, Gaffey could have sentenced him to up to three years and four months in state prison, but at a hearing last Sept. 25 he chose not to send him to prison and instead placed him on five years' felony probation, including one year in the county jail that he could serve at home via electronic monitoring after serving 30 days in jail.

At a hearing two weeks later on Oct. 12, Gaffey reduced Smith's felony hit-and-run conviction to a misdemeanor and reduced his sentence to three years' misdemeanor probation.

At both sentencing hearings, Smith asked to delay serving his jail time because his wife was in delicate health because of her pregnancy and needed bed rest and Gaffey ultimately granted Smith's request.

But prosecutor Matt Gaidos said Smith and his wife then traveled to Dubai for a vacation one week after the Oct. 12 hearing and failed to notify his probation officer, even though he wasn't supposed to travel outside of California.

Gaffey said, "There seem to be some inconsistencies" between what Smith said and his actions afterward.

At a hearing two weeks ago, Gaffey placed Smith back on five years' felony probation and ordered him to serve a year in the county jail after finding that Smith failed to live up to the terms of his probation and his plea agreement with the court by testing positive for cocaine on Oct. 29 after he returned from the trip to Dubai.

Smith was placed in custody at Santa Rita Jail in Dublin in January after he failed to appear in court for a hearing in his case.

Feigelson asked Gaffey Thursday to allow Smith to be placed back on an electronic monitoring program or at least be allowed to serve the rest of his jail term at a facility in Santa Ana so he can be close to his wife and children, but Gaffey denied both requests.

Gaffey said, "The answer is no. Mr. Smith has been given enormous opportunities and he hasn't complied with them. The court is not prepared to give him what he wants because he wants it."

The fatal collision reportedly occurred after Smith had been out drinking with a paralegal from his law firm.

Hu was a Chinese tourist who was in the country for his fiancee's relative's graduation and Smith's case has received widespread attention in China.

Smith was arrested two days after the fatal collision when Dublin police identified him as the owner of a recently purchased black 2012 Mercedes-Benz CLS550 connected with the collision.

Dublin police said Smith's car sustained extensive windshield and front-end damage and was missing parts that were recovered at the scene of the collision.

— Bay City News Service

What is democracy worth to you?
Support local journalism.


30 people like this
Posted by Diane
a resident of Danville
on Feb 25, 2016 at 4:18 pm

This makes my blood boil! This comment "If he's found to have intentionally misled the court, then there could be greater consequences than those that already have been imposed" is ridiculous. How about SOME consequences. I don't consider 3 years of misdemeanor probation after killing a man and intentionally leaving the scene, then violating probation with a vacation in Dubai where he was using cocaine as a consequence - it's a joke! This is completely outrageous.

22 people like this
Posted by Joe
a resident of Blackhawk
on Feb 25, 2016 at 8:35 pm

I completely agree with Diane. This is an absolute joke. This man is making a mockery of the judicial system. He should have been sent straight to prison for the full term after the hit and run and most definitely after lying to the Judge and testing positive for cocaine. Sickening. We need some law makers with a spine. This Judge is obviously lacking.

2 people like this
Posted by Barbara
a resident of Danville
on Feb 26, 2016 at 7:32 am

It is situations like this that make people so angry that they turn to a candidate like Donald Trump for President. What a sad state we are in. This sentence is a joke and so is Trump.

19 people like this
Posted by frankly
a resident of San Ramon
on Feb 26, 2016 at 7:45 am

To have allowed the hit and run killer to get initially get off with a slap on the wrist is and was the fault of this elected judge.

When he comes up for election next time, remember what he did.
He allowed a hit and run killer off with this slap on the wrist.

3 people like this
Posted by Weak Judge
a resident of Danville
on Feb 26, 2016 at 10:50 am

It is really important for the people to vote out corrupt judges at election time. Despite the numerous atrocities committed by this scumbag, the Judge is trying to figure out a way to go easy on him.

4 people like this
Posted by Outraged citizen
a resident of Danville
on Feb 26, 2016 at 10:57 am

Question?? Would Smith had been given so many chances if the hit and run victim was a friend or family member of Gaffey ??
Anyone who runs away from an accident like that should have the book thrown at them, no exceptions!!!!!!

2 people like this
Posted by Nebuchadnezzar
a resident of San Ramon
on Feb 26, 2016 at 8:25 pm

Sadly enough, Gaffey is the scumbag. Smith is an animal

Like this comment
Posted by Diane
a resident of Danville
on Feb 29, 2016 at 10:59 am

Just read this in one of the other articles "Though never stated on the court's record, it is known around the Hayward courthouse that Smith's mother worked for the Alameda County Superior Court for decades." The first judge that was appointed recused himself because he knew too many of the people who wrote letters in support of the defendant. Gaffey should have done the same and let someone who wasn't more concerned with doing a murderer a favor than upholding the law decide this case.

There were also concessions made because the defendant has a prosthetic eye and was supposedly unable to effectively see the man he killed. If he can't see effectively, he should have taken himself off the road. That is not the fault of the victim!

I feel so sorry for the family of the man who was killed.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Plenty of blame to go around for fires and power shutoffs
By Tim Hunt | 9 comments | 704 views

Living as Roommates? Not Having Much Sex?
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 647 views

Tissot Goes to the Movies and the Library
By John A. Barry and Bill Carmel | 1 comment | 452 views