News

What a Week: Lights out in Danville

Town Council to hear from PG&E about scourge of prolonged outages

Someone is finally going to put PG&E under the spotlight for what's been going on in Danville over the last year.

Jeremy Walsh, editorial director. (Photo by Anmarie Fielding-Weeks)

All of us throughout the East Bay have been impacted by power outages due to high winds or atmospheric rivers or public safety power shutoffs (PSPS) or electricity grid concerns during excessive heat. But what Danville residents and businesses continue to experience is absurdity to the extreme.

Town Manager Joe Calabrigo, who is probably the most measured public administrator I've observed in my career, is clearly fed up.

After yet another prolonged power outage, affecting 5,900 customers in Danville over two days (extrapolated out, that's close to one-third of the town's population of 44,000 residents), Calabrigo wrote a letter to the highest executives at the utility company demanding answers for residents. He pulled no punches.

"We've been hearing about everything that PG&E has been doing to improve the power grid in terms of safety and reliability, yet to the many being affected by these outages, things seem to be worse than ever," Calabrigo said in his Aug. 15 letter. "Telling our residents that they should consider buying a generator in 2023 doesn't cut it. Shouldn't our residents be able to expect a system that is safe and reliable?"

Help sustain the local news you depend on.

Your contribution matters. Become a member today.

Join

The letter included an invitation to appear before the Danville Town Council, which PG&E accepted for the regular meeting next Tuesday (Sept. 5). It promises to be a candid discussion.

"PG&E is really starting to piss people off," Danville Mayor Robert Storer told me over the weekend.

"Like most of our residents and especially our business community, we are completely frustrated with the lack of information, especially with absolutely no notice when power will be shut off -- on the enhanced powerline safety settings (EPSS) system -- and no follow-up allowing our residents to better understand when power will be restored," Storer said.

We're still working to collect hard data on the number of major outages in Danville (and Alamo and other nearby unincorporated areas) between summer 2022 and today.

Anecdotally though, I can say I've been stunned so many times over the past year seeing alerts on social media with PG&E maps showing outage areas so large they appear to be pushing square miles, and certainly thousands of homes and dozens of businesses. For hours, even days, at a time.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

And not just the outer edges of the town limits or neighborhoods near dry hills or vast open spaces; the downtown core and other areas right around the freeway have been commonly impacted too.

We're talking more than just people at home not being able to watch TV, kids who can't play video games or retail shops that have to close an hour early.

These are families (by the thousands!) not able to cool their homes during hot summer days in Danville, or heat their homes while sitting in the dark for extra hours in the winter. These are senior residents, parents with infants, people with medical needs such as oxygen tanks and other vulnerable populations forced to uproot for hours or even days – and remember, there are those who can't just do that on a whim, if at all.

These are businesses losing valuable operational time, employees missing out on income, restaurants having to toss food out without refrigeration and vital service appointments being canceled.

The lists go on and on.

"I believe we need to carve out our downtown business community, so they are not affected, and once again only affect the homes in the most high-risk areas," Storer said. "This complete disregard for the community and this extreme inconvenience is beginning to really bother people, especially when power is not available for days with literally no updates in sight."

Storer recalled one time recently when the power was shut off at his Danville home without warning at 6:10 p.m. on a Friday night and restored at 10 a.m. that Saturday, with the first update only coming through at midnight while he was sleeping.

I reached out to PG&E representatives this week for a copy of whatever response they sent to Calabrigo's letter. Spokesperson Tamar Sarkissian only said, "We are continuing to investigate the power outages, and our Bay Area regional vice president will be presenting the latest information at the upcoming meeting" while also referring me to a recent short post from PG&E to customers via Nextdoor.

The message describes ongoing work to repair "damaged underground cable and overhead equipment in the Danville and Alamo communities" that resulted in "some customers are being provided electricity through a different circuit."

"This temporary situation resulted in more customers being impacted when an outage occurred … The temporary grid configuration also meant that a larger portion of the electric system had (EPSS) in place. While these settings help keep you safe, unexpected power outages have occurred," PG&E stated on Nextdoor.

"Losing power for any amount of time is disruptive. We are continuing to look at options to improve reliability in your neighborhood -- without sacrificing safety," the utility company added.

I'm not so sure that did the job to really explain things and quell the understandable frustrations in the San Ramon Valley, especially when their blood has also been boiling due to exorbitant PG&E bills.

Utilities can be a jurisdictional nightmare for people trying to understand which agency (let alone which person) to contact for a straight answer on something that is supposed to be a public necessity. Residents and businesses often turn to their town government when really the power is PG&E's responsibility. Thankfully, Danville's leadership is taking a stand to support their community.

The Town Council hearing is scheduled to begin at 5 p.m. Tuesday (Sept. 5); the agenda report had not been released publicly as of this drafting.

It's a meeting residents should attend or tune into -- assuming, of course, the power stays … well, maybe I shouldn't joke about that, just to be safe.

A front row seat to local high school sports.

Check out our new newsletter, the Playbook.

Editor's note: Jeremy Walsh is the editorial director for the Embarcadero Media East Bay Division. His "What a Week" column is a recurring feature in the Pleasanton Weekly.

Looking for more Livermore stories? The Livermore Vine will be your new source of vital news and information. Sign up to be among the first to get our daily local news headlines sent to your inbox for free.

Jeremy Walsh
 
Jeremy Walsh, a Benicia native and American University alum, joined Embarcadero Media in November 2013. After serving as associate editor for the Pleasanton Weekly and DanvilleSanRamon.com, he was promoted to editor of the East Bay Division in February 2017. Read more >>

Follow DanvilleSanRamon.com on Twitter @DanvilleSanRamo, Facebook and on Instagram @ for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Stay informed on important city government news. Sign up for our FREE daily Express newsletter.

What a Week: Lights out in Danville

Town Council to hear from PG&E about scourge of prolonged outages

by / Danville San Ramon

Uploaded: Thu, Aug 31, 2023, 10:54 am

Someone is finally going to put PG&E under the spotlight for what's been going on in Danville over the last year.

All of us throughout the East Bay have been impacted by power outages due to high winds or atmospheric rivers or public safety power shutoffs (PSPS) or electricity grid concerns during excessive heat. But what Danville residents and businesses continue to experience is absurdity to the extreme.

Town Manager Joe Calabrigo, who is probably the most measured public administrator I've observed in my career, is clearly fed up.

After yet another prolonged power outage, affecting 5,900 customers in Danville over two days (extrapolated out, that's close to one-third of the town's population of 44,000 residents), Calabrigo wrote a letter to the highest executives at the utility company demanding answers for residents. He pulled no punches.

"We've been hearing about everything that PG&E has been doing to improve the power grid in terms of safety and reliability, yet to the many being affected by these outages, things seem to be worse than ever," Calabrigo said in his Aug. 15 letter. "Telling our residents that they should consider buying a generator in 2023 doesn't cut it. Shouldn't our residents be able to expect a system that is safe and reliable?"

The letter included an invitation to appear before the Danville Town Council, which PG&E accepted for the regular meeting next Tuesday (Sept. 5). It promises to be a candid discussion.

"PG&E is really starting to piss people off," Danville Mayor Robert Storer told me over the weekend.

"Like most of our residents and especially our business community, we are completely frustrated with the lack of information, especially with absolutely no notice when power will be shut off -- on the enhanced powerline safety settings (EPSS) system -- and no follow-up allowing our residents to better understand when power will be restored," Storer said.

We're still working to collect hard data on the number of major outages in Danville (and Alamo and other nearby unincorporated areas) between summer 2022 and today.

Anecdotally though, I can say I've been stunned so many times over the past year seeing alerts on social media with PG&E maps showing outage areas so large they appear to be pushing square miles, and certainly thousands of homes and dozens of businesses. For hours, even days, at a time.

And not just the outer edges of the town limits or neighborhoods near dry hills or vast open spaces; the downtown core and other areas right around the freeway have been commonly impacted too.

We're talking more than just people at home not being able to watch TV, kids who can't play video games or retail shops that have to close an hour early.

These are families (by the thousands!) not able to cool their homes during hot summer days in Danville, or heat their homes while sitting in the dark for extra hours in the winter. These are senior residents, parents with infants, people with medical needs such as oxygen tanks and other vulnerable populations forced to uproot for hours or even days – and remember, there are those who can't just do that on a whim, if at all.

These are businesses losing valuable operational time, employees missing out on income, restaurants having to toss food out without refrigeration and vital service appointments being canceled.

The lists go on and on.

"I believe we need to carve out our downtown business community, so they are not affected, and once again only affect the homes in the most high-risk areas," Storer said. "This complete disregard for the community and this extreme inconvenience is beginning to really bother people, especially when power is not available for days with literally no updates in sight."

Storer recalled one time recently when the power was shut off at his Danville home without warning at 6:10 p.m. on a Friday night and restored at 10 a.m. that Saturday, with the first update only coming through at midnight while he was sleeping.

I reached out to PG&E representatives this week for a copy of whatever response they sent to Calabrigo's letter. Spokesperson Tamar Sarkissian only said, "We are continuing to investigate the power outages, and our Bay Area regional vice president will be presenting the latest information at the upcoming meeting" while also referring me to a recent short post from PG&E to customers via Nextdoor.

The message describes ongoing work to repair "damaged underground cable and overhead equipment in the Danville and Alamo communities" that resulted in "some customers are being provided electricity through a different circuit."

"This temporary situation resulted in more customers being impacted when an outage occurred … The temporary grid configuration also meant that a larger portion of the electric system had (EPSS) in place. While these settings help keep you safe, unexpected power outages have occurred," PG&E stated on Nextdoor.

"Losing power for any amount of time is disruptive. We are continuing to look at options to improve reliability in your neighborhood -- without sacrificing safety," the utility company added.

I'm not so sure that did the job to really explain things and quell the understandable frustrations in the San Ramon Valley, especially when their blood has also been boiling due to exorbitant PG&E bills.

Utilities can be a jurisdictional nightmare for people trying to understand which agency (let alone which person) to contact for a straight answer on something that is supposed to be a public necessity. Residents and businesses often turn to their town government when really the power is PG&E's responsibility. Thankfully, Danville's leadership is taking a stand to support their community.

The Town Council hearing is scheduled to begin at 5 p.m. Tuesday (Sept. 5); the agenda report had not been released publicly as of this drafting.

It's a meeting residents should attend or tune into -- assuming, of course, the power stays … well, maybe I shouldn't joke about that, just to be safe.

Editor's note: Jeremy Walsh is the editorial director for the Embarcadero Media East Bay Division. His "What a Week" column is a recurring feature in the Pleasanton Weekly.

Comments

Paul Clark
Registered user
Danville
on Aug 31, 2023 at 7:10 pm
Paul Clark, Danville
Registered user
on Aug 31, 2023 at 7:10 pm

Jeremy,

Well-written and well-researched article. We have experienced at least three fairly long electrical service outages thus far this year. We are fortunate to have a 3Kw gasoline engine-driven generator (that we have to use with our travel trailer). It is a hassle to string extension cords to keep the basic stuff energized, but I can imagine how this kind of service interruption affects people whose very lives depend their electricity being on all the time, and do not have a backup.
My personal belief is that PG&E may be skimping on the scheduled maintenance of their outside plant and the replacement of components before they reach their end of life. As a company, having had immense unplanned expenses associated with the recent wildfires and their liability for same it may make sense for them to be running stuff until it fails. The Town of Danville needs to step up and make sure PG&E takes care of their customers.


Parent and Voter
Registered user
Danville
on Sep 1, 2023 at 6:33 am
Parent and Voter, Danville
Registered user
on Sep 1, 2023 at 6:33 am

While not a fan of PG&E it should be noted that East Bay Mud also has ignored proper maintenance over the years and then is planning to hit consumers with much higher costs to cover activities that should have been budgeted over the years.
Also note that the push for urbanization of communities with high density housing puts a strain on our infrastructure. Plus the push for electric cars and electric cooktops, water heaters, furnaces, etc strains our existing infrastructure
I am not giving a free pass to PG&E but blame also should be placed on Sacramento and some of our local leadership. Just my opinion.


Paul Clark
Registered user
Danville
on Sep 1, 2023 at 8:36 am
Paul Clark, Danville
Registered user
on Sep 1, 2023 at 8:36 am

To Parent & Voter:
All our "Public Utilities" are in the same boat! PG&E, Central San, EBMUD and now Republic Services, are poor service providers and it's largely because they are being forced to knuckle under to Sacramento and the loony tunes up there who are trying to pass for "leaders." All of the PU's perennially have their hands in our pockets to fund things that are usually detrimental to our interests. And if you read their proposals, often you find that a major cost they want to cover is improvements to their own pensions.
You can't run public utilities to serve 40 million people with an infrastructure that hasn't been improved since California had only $20 million residents. EBMUD said that now we're once again awash in water, they were going to lower rates, but my bill is the same as it was last year for about the same usage.
We own another home in Carmel. Several years ago, PG&E had a citywide program to "line" all their gas distribution lines because they are very old and were leaking. I showed up one day to find crews, without my permission preparing to move our gas meter, which was under a kitchen window, to a spot where it would block an access stairway. I told them that they could not make the move. The issue was that it couldn't be under a window that opened (mind you the house was built in 1940 and the meter had always been there). So the supervisor was called and he agreed the move was inappropriate. They would "fix" the problem by putting an extension on the gas regulator vent. That was four years ago, but they've never come back to put in the vent. Oh, and during their "project" they managed to actually blow up a home, and as a consequence of the follow-on lawsuit, agreed to pave most of the streets in Carmel that they had dug up, rather than just patching over their ditches. Go Figure!


Highlander
Registered user
Montair Elementary School
on Sep 1, 2023 at 9:23 am
Highlander, Montair Elementary School
Registered user
on Sep 1, 2023 at 9:23 am

I've installed solar, a Tesla Powerwall and Generac generator since we have essentially become a third-world State. The Tesla system tracks outages showing that the power has gone out for various periods of time 30+ times since I had the system installed in 2019 including one outage that lasted for three days!


D
Registered user
Danville
on Sep 1, 2023 at 11:32 am
D, Danville
Registered user
on Sep 1, 2023 at 11:32 am

Excellent old school journalism-great job Jeremy!

I fully understand when the power goes out during an extreme storm, or a car hits a power pole, but in 2023 we have had repeated loss of power for hours for no good reason. I applaud you Jeremy for writing an objective, well researched, article that serves the public good. No political ideology or ax to grind, as PG & E's horrible service affects everyone, and will only get worse when the weather gets worse, unless the pressure is put on PG & E.

PG & E has always put their shareholders above the public safety, so we need our political leaders to come up with ways that affect their shareholders, and make them demand better service from the company.

How about during the upcoming Town Council meeting with PG & E, we get them to agree to a policy where if a household or business in Danville loses power more than once a month, the household or business gets an automatic $100 rebate on next month's bill? No more useless rhetoric from PG & E about excuses for the power routinely going out, hold them financially accountable to the public they allegedly serve. How about it Danville town council members, are you ready to speak up for your constituents during this meeting, and actually hold PG & E financially responsible for their malfeasance?


Paul Clark
Registered user
Danville
on Sep 1, 2023 at 12:40 pm
Paul Clark, Danville
Registered user
on Sep 1, 2023 at 12:40 pm

To all interested parties

You should go on the web and read how our Governor has bailed out PG&E. I won't post any articles because this news source would probably take it down, but there are reputable sources ( like ABC Channel 7) who have written about the way Newsom bailed PG&E out after all the fires it caused, using taxpayer dollars to do so. So we pay both ways.


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.